K2.0 Small Talk: Is it better here or there?
Chronicle and photographs from the event
WHAT'S UP WITH THE DIASPORA?
By Ngadhnjim Avdyli - 20.07.2018
K2.0 discusses the important role of the diaspora.
On July 19, at Innovation Center Kosovo, K2.0 held a discussion about the role of the diaspora titled “Is it better here or there?”. Questions about the diaspora’s contribution throughout the years and whether or not its members can be seen as a homogenous group were addressed, as well as whether or not the diaspora can escape the framework which perceives them as a financial source, and the role of institutions in dealing with the diaspora.
The discussion panel, moderated by journalist Eraldin Fazliu, was comprised of: Afrim Bekteshi, the Deputy Minister for the Diaspora and Strategic Investments, Osman Osmani, the head of the Prointegra.ch professional association, Liza Gashi from the Germin organization, and Adem Ferizaj, MA in International Relations from the Paris Institute of Political Studies, who was raised in Germany.
Fazliu opened the discussion with the question of whether or not members of the diaspora are seen only as a financial source, based on the second part of the name — Strategic Investments — of the Ministry of the Diaspora. He spoke about the shortage of information, mentioning the Ministry’s webpage and its lack of updates.
Deputy Minister Bekteshi said that the second part of the ministry’s name should not be problematic because foreign investments must be secured, and members of the diaspora can contribute with their connections. Furthermore, in response to criticism about the lack of activity on the ministry’s webpage, Deputy Minister Bekteshi admitted that the webpage is not functioning properly and that there is a lack of information because the ministry itself suffers from a shortage of data.
He did not offer a solution for this problem, but he said that “information is a resource which facilitates the initiation of processes,” and highlighted that he has served in his position for a short period of time.
Bekteshi went on to unfold the Ministry’s plans for the future, saying that they are preparing a new strategic document which contains four objectives for the next five years, including “the promotion and advancement of the diaspora’s political rights in Kosovo’s institutions, the preservation of the cultural identity of members of the diaspora, and the integration and inclusion of the diaspora in socio-economic processes in Kosovo.”
The deputy minister did not provide extensive details about what steps they plan to take to implement these objectives or about when we can expect to see concrete results, but he went on to criticize institutions, saying that he is “not satisfied with what has been done until now.”
After the representative from the ministry, next to speak was Prointegra.ch’s Osman Osmani, who has lived in Switzerland for more than four decades and has worked with social insurance for many years. He spoke about Kosovo’s diplomatic representation in European countries which he labelled as “full of [political] party militants, just like in Kosovo,” going on to say that this is the reason why there is no space for professionals. The deputy minister agreed with this assessment, highlighting that the same situation is found in the Ministry that he is a part of.
Analyzing the work of institutions regarding the diaspora, Osmani mentioned social insurance and the inter-state agreement with Switzerland which was annulled nine years ago. According to him, this is because professionals are not a part of institutions. Regarding this development, he also criticized the Swiss state, because the price is being paid by Kosovo’s pensioners who have worked in Switzerland for years.
“The problems that members of the diaspora face are not problems of one individual or one institution in particular, rather it is a structural problem that also affects international missions and countries that are part of these missions,” said Osmani.
For Liza Gashi, director of the Germin organization, the Ministry of the Diaspore and Strategic Investment’s budget of 1.7 million euros demonstrates the extent of the work that local institutions do, as well as their unserious approach towards the diaspora.
Gashi also spoke about 900,000 Kosovars who live in different countries — a figure provided by the Kosovo Agency of Statistics — saying that when we speak about members of the diaspora, we must not refer to them as a homogenous entity. “It is very important to understand that we cannot generalize and say that the diaspora wants this,” she said.
According to Gashi, the waves in which they left Kosovo dictate the diaspora’s way of living and the realities in which they live. “It is quite different when you meet a migrant that left in the ’60s and is a pensioner today, and when you meet his children, who have no emotional ties with Kosovo like their parents do,” said Gashi.
Based on this, she said that problems must be addressed in a few fields and called to put an end to disinformation, going on to say that we must understand that we are dealing with people of different profiles and experiences who have different objectives and approaches.
Meanwhile, Adem Ferizaj started the conversation with a story from his personal experience. While he was researching for his master’s thesis in Kosovo, he was contacted by the Kosovo Embassy in Paris. Representatives from the Embassy asked Ferizaj to provide data about the number of Albanian students in the French capital, “because the Kosovo Ambassador wanted to meet them for a cultural event.”
“What this implied is that in a European capital, Kosovar officials have no database of students from Kosovo that study in Paris,” he said, taking the example of Paris as a demonstration of the general situation regarding work that institutions do.
Furthermore, he said that the time had come to add to the criticism and analyze why the situation was not improving. According to Ferizaj, the essence of the problem is that Kosovo is a marginalized and colonized political entity which has no opportunity to act.
“So what are we expecting from politicians, who in reality have no power and are only marionettes of others who are simply satisfied that there is no longer a war going on in Kosovo?” he asked. For Ferizaj, we must first criticize our approach, then speak about other fields.
Moreover, the young man who has lived in Kosovo for the last couple of years spoke about the term “schatzi,” which according to him is a racist construct. For Ferizaj, Kosovars have borrowed this term from the hegemonic and orientalizing approach of German and Swiss people towards Kosovars living in those countries. He finds it ironic that this term finds space and is used in Kosovo, adding that members of the diaspora are being excluded in the country.
Ferizaj also spoke about job opportunities in Kosovo, saying that they are limited for all citizens.
Photos: Majlinda Hoxha / K2.0.
About this Talk
Join us for our latest Small Talk on Thursday, July 19 at the Innovation Centre of Kosovo.
Kosovo’s diaspora has long played a vital role in supporting the well-being of those back home. From collecting funds and lobbying internationally for the rights of Kosovar Albanians living under an oppressive regime during the ’90s, to subsidising family members and investing in the post-war and post-independence state.
Today, with diaspora remittances making up 16 percent of Kosovo’s GDP, the role of the diaspora in many people’s minds seems to have evolved into being considered almost exclusively a financial resource. In the meantime, aiming to organize its diaspora and reach out to them, Kosovo has established the Ministry of Diaspora and Strategic Investments.
But the profile of the diaspora has changed with the times. After the ‘Gastarbeiters’ of the ’60s and ’70s and those seeking refuge in the ’90s, a new face of the diaspora is now emerging as a considerable number of Kosovar citizens pursue their academic and professional development abroad. And, just like Kosovar citizens at home, many of those who have left have become increasingly frustrated with a lack of progress in developing a fully functioning state.
So often referred to as a simple collective and derogatorily dubbed ‘Schatzis,’ it’s time to look beyond the ‘Is it better here or there?’ And to recognize the complex, multi-layered realities of Kosovars living overseas, and their relationship with Kosovo.
Will members of the diaspora ever be acknowledged as more than a mere financial resource? What can students studying abroad add to Kosovo’s intellectual capital for development? What exactly is the role of the Ministry of Diaspora and Strategic Investments? What are the experiences of members of the diaspora when it comes to dealing with Kosovar institutions? Are the political rights and concerns of members of the diaspora being properly addressed? What have Kosovo’s institutions done to utilize the diaspora’s potential?
On Thursday, July 19, at 18:00 we will discuss all of these issues and more in our latest participative Small Talk, held at Innovation Centre Kosovo (Rexhep Mala Str. 28A Prishtina, Kosovo)
To initiate the discussion, we will be joined by:
– Afrim Bekteshi – Deputy Minister for Diaspora and Strategic Investments
– Liza Gashi – Executive director of Germin (an NGO that uses technology and virtual channels to connect and engage Western Balkan members of the diaspora in advancing the development and democratization of their home countries).
– Osman Osmani – Chairman of the professional association “Prointegra.ch” from Switzerland (an association built by professionals from Kosovo for migration issues)
– Adem Ferizaj – Brought up in Germany, has an MA in International Relations at Paris Institute of Political Studies (Sciences Po Paris)
The discussion will be moderated by Eraldin Fazliu. Translation in English will be provided.K
Watch this edition now
About the speakers